On November 3, six progressive Christian clergy or lay leaders won their elections, according to Baptist News Global. [2] Adam Hamilton, a Methodist pastor in Kansas, won a U.S. Senate seat. So did James Talarico, a Presbyterian seminarian in Texas, who defeated Ken Paxton. [2][3]
Now the question is landing in church foyers and at kitchen tables: What is progressive Christianity? Is it the same faith I was raised on?
Let me say something first. Progressive Christians care about the poor, the immigrant, and the person on the margins. So does the Bible. This article is not about whether Christians should care. We should. It is about the framework behind the caring. Is it the Christianity of the Bible, or something else wearing the same name? [1]
Two cautions. Progressive Christianity is not a denomination or a creed. Its own network asks people to hold its core values “lightly but seriously.” [4] So no two progressives believe exactly alike, and I am not saying any person named here believes all ten of these. Where I name Talarico, I use his own recorded words. Second, I am writing about theology, not anyone’s heart. God alone judges that. Analysts also note that being a pastor was not the main reason these candidates won. [3]
Here are ten differences. Under each one I give you a question you can ask any pastor, author, or candidate who wants your trust on matters of faith.
1. The authority of the Bible
Historic Christianity holds that the Bible is God’s Word, and that it judges us. “All Scripture is God-breathed and is useful for teaching, rebuking, correcting and training in righteousness” (2 Timothy 3:16, NIV).
Some progressive approaches treat parts of Scripture as the limited product of ancient cultures, and let today’s moral convictions decide which teachings still bind us. [1] One critic calls the result a buffet: take what you like, leave what you don’t. Reading a passage in its context is honest interpretation. But the great danger is letting my presuppositions tell the Bible what it means, instead of letting the Bible correct me. [1]
The question to ask: Does the Bible correct my views, or do my views decide what the Bible is allowed to say?
2. Who Jesus is
Peter answered Jesus, “You are the Messiah, the Son of the living God” (Matthew 16:16, NIV). Jesus said why he came: “For the Son of Man came to seek and to save the lost” (Luke 19:10, NIV). Historic Christianity confesses him as the eternal Son of God, fully God and fully man.
In many progressive expressions Jesus is mainly a challenger of oppressive systems, a teacher of radical love and inclusion. [1] He did show compassion to the poor and the outcast. But that was not the center of his mission. He came to seek and save the lost.
The question to ask: Is Jesus the Son of God who saves, or an example to admire?
3. Why Jesus died
Jesus said he came “to give his life as a ransom for many” (Mark 10:45, NIV). Paul wrote, “God made him who had no sin to be sin for us, so that in him we might become the righteousness of God” (2 Corinthians 5:21, NIV). Historic Christianity teaches that Jesus died in the place of sinners.
Writing for Day1, the Rev. Dr. Greg Love observes that many progressive Christians reject the doctrine of atonement altogether and say Jesus saves through his life rather than his death. [8] A Baptist News Global essay argues that the substitution view makes God guilty of something like child abuse. [9] The Bible answers that Jesus was no unwilling victim: “No one takes it from me, but I lay it down of my own accord” (John 10:18, NIV). Even Richard Beck, in a series he titles “Post-Progressive Christianity,” grants that progressives have fair objections to some penal versions of the doctrine, yet says the biblical witness is clear that Jesus’ death was substitutionary and atoning. [10]
The question to ask: Did Jesus die for my sins, or only show me how to live?
4. The resurrection
Historic Christianity teaches that Jesus rose bodily. The risen Jesus said, “Look at my hands and my feet. It is I myself! Touch me and see; a ghost does not have flesh and bones, as you see I have” (Luke 24:39, NIV). Paul adds, “And if Christ has not been raised, your faith is futile; you are still in your sins” (1 Corinthians 15:17, NIV).
Marcus Borg, one of the best-known voices of progressive Christianity, wrote that he does not think Easter means Jesus is a physical, bodily reality. He treated the appearances as visions and said the meaning of Easter does not depend on a miracle happening to the body. [6] In a 1999 PBS discussion, N.T. Wright said plainly that he says yes to the bodily resurrection and Borg says no. [7] Not every progressive follows Borg, but his is a well-worn road.
The question to ask: Did the tomb really empty, and did Jesus rise in a body?
5. What is wrong with the world
Historic Christianity says the problem begins in the human heart: “for all have sinned and fall short of the glory of God” (Romans 3:23, NIV). Jesus began his ministry with the call, “Repent and believe the good news!” (Mark 1:15, NIV), and told Nicodemus, “no one can see the kingdom of God unless they are born again” (John 3:3, NIV).
Progressive teaching puts heavy weight on unjust systems and structures. Beck observes that progressive Christianity has a hard time seeing the world as lost, and that if no one is lost, there is no need for salvation. [10] Unjust systems are real, and Christians should oppose them. But in my own Wesleyan roots we learned that sin is a heart problem before it is a systems problem, and that the cure is the new birth.
The question to ask: Does this teacher say I need to be born again, or only that the world needs fixing?
6. How a person is saved
“For it is by grace you have been saved, through faith—and this is not from yourselves, it is the gift of God—not by works, so that no one can boast” (Ephesians 2:8–9, NIV). Good works follow: “For we are God’s handiwork, created in Christ Jesus to do good works” (Ephesians 2:10, NIV).
When salvation is treated mainly as social improvement, the eternal side of the gospel fades. When good works are offered as the way to earn God’s acceptance, salvation becomes our achievement instead of God’s gift. [1] Beck warns that, left unqualified, progressive teaching can make salvation wholly up to us, and that the pursuit of social justice without grace and atonement turns dark. [11]
The question to ask: Is salvation a gift I receive, or a project I carry out?
7. Is Jesus the only way
“I am the way and the truth and the life. No one comes to the Father except through me” (John 14:6, NIV). “Salvation is found in no one else, for there is no other name under heaven given to mankind by which we must be saved” (Acts 4:12, NIV). “For there is one God and one mediator between God and mankind, the man Christ Jesus” (1 Timothy 2:5, NIV).
Some who identify as progressive Christians reject exclusive claims outright. [5] In a 2023 sermon titled “God Is Not a Christian,” Talarico spoke of “many pathways to the sacred.” [12] Christians should honor the good in their neighbors and defend their religious liberty. But protecting a neighbor’s freedom to believe is not the same as saying every path is true. From Noah’s ark to the Passover lamb to the bronze serpent in the wilderness, God has always supplied one appointed way of rescue. [1]
This attack on Christ’s exclusivity has reached Christian campuses too. A recent report from Point Loma Nazarene University says a dean told students that an identity “in Christ alone” reflects white privilege. [16] I give that as a reported allegation, not a proven quote. The charge came from an Instagram document, the dean declined to comment on that statement, and the university said his views fall within the context of a Christian education. [16] Scripture is plain that the Gospel is offered to everyone alike, and that salvation comes through Christ alone (John 3:16–18; 1 Timothy 2:5).
The question to ask: Is Jesus one of many roads to God, or the only way?
If you want help standing firm for your children and grandchildren, that is why I wrote Not On My Watch: A Grandfather’s Call to Reclaim Faith, Family, and Freedom: amazon.com/dp/B0GT4PK36X
8. Who God is
Jesus taught us to pray, “Our Father in heaven, hallowed be your name” (Matthew 6:9, NIV). He also said, “God is spirit, and his worshipers must worship in the Spirit and in truth” (John 4:24, NIV).
Talarico has said “God is nonbinary,” in the course of supporting transgender youth playing on sports teams. [13] He later explained he meant that God transcends human gender categories. [1] Historic Christianity agrees that God is spirit and has no biological sex, and Scripture uses a mother’s tenderness as a picture of his care: “As a mother comforts her child, so will I comfort you” (Isaiah 66:13, NIV). But God has also told us how to speak of him: Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. The issue is not which word sounds more welcoming. It is whether our words about God follow what he has revealed about himself. [1]
The question to ask: Do we describe God as he reveals himself, or by the categories of the moment?
9. Sexuality, marriage, and life
Jesus pointed back to creation: “Haven’t you read,” he replied, “that at the beginning the Creator ‘made them male and female’” (Matthew 19:4, NIV). Traditional Christian teaching draws marriage and sexual morality from the creation account, the words of Jesus, and the apostles.
Progressive leaders often note that the Bible never mentions abortion or same-sex marriage by name, while they appeal to Scripture to defend LGBT inclusion. But the absence of a modern term does not mean the Bible is silent on a modern question. [1] Christians who hold the historic view owe every person dignity and kindness. Paul’s phrase is “speaking the truth in love” (Ephesians 4:15, NIV). Truth without love becomes cruelty. But love and moral affirmation are not the same thing. [1]
The question to ask: When the Bible is silent on a modern word, is it also silent on the question?
10. How doctrine is held
“Dear friends… I felt compelled to write to you and urge you to contend for the faith that was entrusted to God’s holy people once for all” (Jude 3, NIV). Paul warned that a time would come when people “will not put up with sound doctrine” and will gather teachers “to say what their itching ears want to hear” (2 Timothy 4:3, NIV).
The movement’s own literature describes a faith that finds more in the search for understanding than in certainty. [15] In his February 2026 interview with Stephen Colbert, Talarico said, “Don’t tell me what you believe. Show me how you treat other people.” [14] I agree that faith without deeds is dead. But Christianity is not only a way of treating people. It is a message about what God has done in Christ, and it is handed down to be believed and guarded.
The question to ask: Will this teacher tell me plainly what he believes about Jesus, the cross, and the empty tomb?
The battle in front of the church
The fight in America is no longer only about whether Christianity will have a place in public life. It is about which understanding of Christianity will shape that life. [1] Many people sitting in the pews cannot tell the difference, because the same words (Jesus, grace, love, kingdom) are used by both sides. That is why the ten questions matter.
C.S. Lewis saw this trick coming. In “Screwtape Proposes a Toast,” published in 1959 as a sequel to The Screwtape Letters, a senior devil tells young tempters that the way to ruin people is not to throw out good words but to twist them. [17] In Lewis’s story, “democracy” is bent until it serves envy. The same method works with other good words. When “inclusion,” “love,” and “grace” are stretched until they no longer mean what Jesus meant, the word stays and the Gospel leaves. The devil always twists what is good. So test the meaning behind the word, and ask the ten questions.
Your Turn
Read the Gospel of John this week with a pencil, and mark everything Jesus says about himself.
Ask the ten questions above of any pastor, author, or candidate who asks for your trust on faith. Their answers will tell you more than their biography.
Read your own church’s statement of faith. Ask whether it says what you assumed it says.
Treat people on every side with respect. “But in your hearts revere Christ as Lord. Always be prepared to give an answer to everyone who asks you to give the reason for the hope that you have. But do this with gentleness and respect” (1 Peter 3:15, NIV).
Subscribe to Mo Hodge Ministries in Substack. This Saturday: the story of Squanto, the man God prepared to save the Pilgrims.
Soli Deo gloria.
My Books:
Not On My Watch: A Grandfather’s Call to Reclaim Faith, Family, and Freedom, my marching orders for grandparents and parents: amazon.com/dp/B0GT4PK36X
American Founders Storybook: Twelve Lives God Formed to Birth a Nation: amazon.com/dp/B0H1XNHRLR
The One Tree (Book One of the Mo Hodge Legacy Series): amazon.com/dp/B0GS5V8D87
At Death’s Door, Nancy’s and my testimony: amazon.com/dp/B0HD2JQ1WQ
Ten Lies Teachers Are Taught. Coming on December 4th on Amazon and Ingram-Spark.
Source Notes
[1] Mark Creech, “Progressive Christians won big: The culture war’s new front,” op-ed, November 15, 2026. This article develops the four theological concerns raised there: the authority of Scripture, the identity and mission of Jesus, the uniqueness of Christ, and biblical morality and the nature of God.
[2] Baptist News Global, “Six progressive Christian leaders win in midterms.” baptistnews.com
[3] Associated Press, “Democratic candidates with a Christian message help flip Congress,” November 6, 2026 (including political scientist Ryan Burge’s caution). wbtv.com
[4] ProgressiveChristianity.org core values, as reported by Patheos, “The 8 Points of Progressive Christianity Have Changed. Here’s What They Are Now.” patheos.com
[5] Center for Progressive Christianity, overview of who may be considered progressive Christians. wikipedia.org
[6] Marcus Borg, “The Resurrection of Jesus: Physical/Bodily or Spiritual/Mystical?” Patheos, April 2011. patheos.com
[7] PBS Religion & Ethics NewsWeekly, “The Resurrection of Jesus,” March 26, 1999 (N.T. Wright and Marcus Borg). pbs.org
[8] Greg Love, “The Meaning of the Cross: Alternative Views of the Atonement,” Day1. day1.org
[9] Baptist News Global, “Rethinking the atonement.” baptistnews.com
[10] Richard Beck, “Post-Progressive Christianity: Part 7, Salvation.” richardbeck.substack.com
[11] Richard Beck, “Post-Progressive Christianity, Part 7,” Experimental Theology (same series). experimentaltheology.blogspot.com
[12] The Daily Wire, “Talarico Says ‘God Is Not A Christian’ In Unearthed Sermon” (reporting on his October 22, 2023 sermon). dailywire.com
[13] Religion Unplugged, “‘God Is Nonbinary’: Is Saying So Political Suicide?” religionunplugged.com
[14] ChurchLeaders, “Douglas Wilson and James Talarico Have Brought the Christian Nationalism Debate Back Into the Spotlight” (Talarico’s Colbert interview, February 2026). churchleaders.com
[15] Progressive Christianity Network Britain, “The Eight Points.” pcnbritain.org.uk
[16] WND, “Report: Dean of divinity school claims being ‘in Christ alone’ is white privilege” (reporting on Point Loma Nazarene University and citing The College Fix; a reported allegation). wnd.com
[17] C.S. Lewis, “Screwtape Proposes a Toast,” Saturday Evening Post, 1959 (sequel to The Screwtape Letters); publication details from wikipedia.org. Commentary on the essay supplied by Mo Hodge.
Scripture quotations are taken from the Holy Bible, New International Version®, NIV®. Copyright © 1973, 1978, 1984, 2011 by Biblica, Inc.® Used by permission. All rights reserved worldwide.




0 Comments