Dr. John Seel
on November 16, 2026

THE FORMATION COLLEGES: Why Micro Colleges May Be the Best Investment in a Young Adult’s Future

If you want to form a different kind of person, you must create a different kind of environment.

image 2ddcc69d

19 min read

The value proposition of a college degree is increasingly in question. More young people and their parents are asking whether four years of college, the enormous expense, and the prospect of substantial debt are worth the investment. It is a fair question. For many students, the answer may be “No.”

Too many young people go to college simply because it is what comes after high school. They have little understanding of who they are, what they want to do with their lives, or why they are pursuing a particular degree. They arrive without a compelling purpose and leave four years later with a diploma, considerable debt, and many of the same unanswered questions.

This is an expensive way to postpone adulthood. At some institutions, the annual cost approaches that of pushing a new Mercedes-Benz off a cliff every year.

For students who are uncertain about their future, community college, an apprenticeship, military service, or a period of employment may be a wiser first step. College should never be the default.

But what about young people who want something more from their education? What about those who want to be challenged intellectually, formed spiritually, and prepared to assume meaningful responsibilities in the world?

For them, an emerging alternative deserves serious consideration. It is called the micro college. I prefer another name: the formation college.

The distinction matters because the real innovation is not simply the size of the institution. It is what the institution understands education to be.

Elite Students, Not Elite Schools

We ordinarily associate elite higher education with the Ivy League and a handful of prestigious universities. Admission is competitive, tuition is expensive, and the institutional brand carries considerable social influence.

But there is another way to think about educational excellence. What if we focused less on elite institutions and more on students with elite aspirations?

I am not speaking about intellectual superiority, family wealth, or social status. I am speaking about young people who want to become the best versions of themselves. They are willing to work hard, accept correction, develop discipline, and assume responsibility for something larger than their own success. They want their lives to count.

In military language, they aspire to become the special forces of kingdom service. They want to be equipped to serve at the tip of the spear, where character, competence, courage, and commitment matter most.

Such students are not necessarily the ones with the highest standardized test scores. They are the ones willing to be formed. This is the distinctive promise of the formation college.

Small by Design

Micro colleges have emerged as an alternative to the increasingly complex and expensive structure of conventional higher education.

Most are small, sometimes enrolling fewer than one hundred students. Many emphasize the liberal arts, although some incorporate entrepreneurship, trade skills, professional certifications, or substantial work experience.

Their faculty members are often generalists capable of teaching across several disciplines. Students typically encounter the same professors repeatedly, both inside and outside the classroom. The result is a more personal educational experience. Students are known. Their strengths are recognized. Their weaknesses are difficult to hide. Their intellectual development can be observed over time.

There is little room for anonymity.

This contrasts with the industrial assumptions underlying much of modern higher education. Large institutions must organize thousands of students into standardized courses, administrative systems, and measurable outcomes. These structures are necessary at scale, but they do not always encourage the personal attention essential to formation.

A university may know how many students graduate without knowing whether those graduates have become mature adults. A formation college asks a different question.

What kind of person is this student becoming? That question changes almost everything.

There is, however, an important qualification.

Many of these emerging institutions are not institutionally accredited. Some operate under state religious exemptions or through other legally permitted arrangements. This can substantially reduce operating costs and allow greater curricular flexibility. But it also creates genuine limitations. Transfer credits may not be accepted, graduate schools may decline admission, professional licensing may be unavailable, and federal financial aid may not apply.

These are not minor considerations. Families must investigate them carefully before enrolling. I suspect alternative institutions such as micro colleges will gain greater recognition as they establish strong academic records and demonstrate the quality of their graduates. Homeschooling provides an instructive example of an educational alternative that gradually gained broader acceptance.

But recognition is not automatic, and families should not assume that it will arrive in time to benefit a particular student. The value proposition of a formation college must therefore rest upon something more substantial than a conventional credential.

It rests upon two things: maturity and mission.

Adulting 101

The first distinctive of a formation college is its commitment to maturation. College should not be an expensive extension of adolescence.

Yet for many young people, this is precisely what it has become. The conventional college experience often emphasizes independence, self-discovery, entertainment, and social life. Students leave home, acquire considerable personal freedom, and enter a peer culture with relatively little adult supervision. Some flourish in this environment. Others struggle.

The challenges are familiar: excessive drinking, sexual pressure, loneliness, academic disengagement, anxiety, and uncertainty about the future.

These problems cannot all be blamed on universities. They reflect broader cultural conditions affecting young adults. But the social environment of a college can either intensify these pressures or help students develop the maturity necessary to navigate them.

This is where formation colleges take a different approach.

Students may be expected to work alongside their studies. They prepare meals, clean shared spaces, maintain facilities, and contribute to the daily responsibilities of their community. They learn to show up on time. They discover that other people depend upon them. They encounter the consequences of failing to keep commitments. They learn to work with people they did not choose, resolve disagreements, and repair relationships after conflict. These experiences may appear ordinary. They are anything but. They are the habits of adulthood.

A young person does not become responsible simply by attending lectures about responsibility. Responsibility is learned by accepting responsibilities. Nor does someone become a mature adult merely by studying theories of human relationships. Maturity develops through the difficult, often inconvenient work of living well with other people.

This is why so much of the educational value of a formation college occurs outside the classroom. The classroom provides intellectual understanding. The community provides daily opportunities to put that understanding into practice. The two reinforce one another.

The Hidden Curriculum of Student Life

There is an important educational principle at work here. Students are formed not only by what they are taught but also by the social environments in which they live. A college may offer excellent courses in ethics, theology, philosophy, and literature. But if its student culture consistently rewards irresponsibility, self-indulgence, and social conformity, the lessons learned outside the classroom may undermine those taught within it. Student life is never educationally neutral. It possesses a curriculum of its own.

The question is whether that curriculum is intentional. At a formation college, the daily rhythm of life is designed to reinforce the institution’s educational purposes. Faculty members become mentors rather than distant lecturers. Older students model expectations for younger students. Shared work becomes an occasion for developing responsibility. Common meals encourage conversation. Worship and spiritual disciplines orient the community toward realities larger than individual preference. The student is surrounded by a culture that makes certain habits normal.

This is not always comfortable. Indeed, students accustomed to organizing life around personal preference may find the experience demanding. But growth rarely occurs without discomfort.

Consider military boot camp. Its purpose is not merely to teach recruits a collection of technical skills. It introduces them to a new identity, a shared mission, and habits of discipline, responsibility, and mutual dependence.

Formation colleges are not military institutions, nor should they imitate every feature of military training. But they recognize a similar principle. If you want to form a different kind of person, you must create a different kind of environment. This is the hidden strength of the formation college. It does not leave personal development to chance.

The Quarter-Life Crisis

The need for this approach becomes clearer when we consider the challenges facing emerging adults.

Psychologists use the term quarter-life crisis to describe a period of uncertainty about identity, work, relationships, belonging, and life direction, often experienced between the twenties and early thirties. Surveys suggest these struggles are widespread, although estimates vary depending upon how the experience is defined and measured. The deeper problem is not simply that young people are uncertain about their careers. Many are uncertain about what makes a life meaningful. They have been encouraged to pursue their passions, discover their authentic selves, and construct lives reflecting their personal preferences. But what happens when those preferences change? What happens when personal fulfillment proves insufficient to sustain a meaningful life? What happens when freedom of choice produces confusion rather than clarity? 

A culture that places enormous emphasis upon self-discovery does not necessarily provide the resources needed for self-understanding. Young people need more than options. They need a compelling understanding of what adulthood is for. This is where the formation college can make an extraordinary difference. It does not simply ask students what they want to become. It asks what kind of people they ought to become and what responsibilities they are called to accept. The distinction is profound.

An Education in the Why Questions

The second distinctive of the formation college is mission. Most students enter college thinking primarily about what they will study and what career they might pursue. These are legitimate concerns. But they are not the deepest educational questions. Why should I pursue this career? What makes work meaningful? What responsibilities do I have toward others? What constitutes a good life? What is worth sacrificing for? What kind of person should I become?

These are the questions of liberal education.

They are also the questions that increasingly go unanswered in contemporary culture.

A serious liberal arts education introduces students to the great conversations that have shaped Western civilization. Philosophy, history, literature, theology, mathematics, science, and the arts become pathways toward understanding the nature of reality and the human condition. Students encounter thinkers who challenge their assumptions. They learn to distinguish argument from assertion. They discover that their personal preferences are not the final measure of truth. They begin to recognize the relationship between knowledge, character, and responsibility.

In a formation college, these questions are not confined to the classroom. They become part of the ongoing conversation of the community. The student studying Aristotle’s account of virtue must also confront the practical demands of developing good habits.

The student reading Augustine’s Confessions must consider the ordering of personal loves.

The student studying the biblical understanding of work must also show up for an assigned shift. The student discussing Christian community must learn to live with an irritating roommate. This is education with consequences. It is not simply the accumulation of information. It is the integration of knowledge and life.

The Importance of Transcendence

At the best Christian formation colleges, worship is not an extracurricular activity. It is part of the institution’s understanding of reality. Prayer, Scripture, liturgy, music, and shared spiritual disciplines remind students that their lives belong within a larger story. This matters enormously.

We are living in a culture increasingly uncertain about the existence of objective meaning.

Young people are frequently told that meaning must be constructed through personal choice. Christian education begins with a different assumption. Meaning is not simply invented. It is discovered and received within a created order that possesses purposes beyond our individual preferences. The student is not an autonomous individual whose highest calling is self-expression. The student is a person created in the image of God, possessing dignity, responsibilities, and a vocation to love and serve others.

This understanding changes the purpose of education.

Academic excellence remains important. Vocational preparation remains important. But neither is sufficient. Education should help students recognize their place within God’s larger purposes and equip them to participate faithfully in those purposes. This is what gives the formation college its distinctive mission. It seeks to unite intellectual development, spiritual maturity, practical responsibility, and vocational calling within a single educational experience.

Different Schools, Different Emphases

Formation colleges are not identical. St. Andrew’s College, Excel College, Hildegard College, Gutenberg College, Ralston College are all different. Some emphasize classical learning and the great books. Others place greater weight upon liturgical worship, music, and the arts. Some incorporate entrepreneurship and business development. Others require substantial work experience or vocational training. Some emphasize outdoor education, craftsmanship, agriculture, or community service. These differences are healthy. There is no single institutional model appropriate for every student.

The important commonality is the conviction that education should form the whole person. Students should leave not only knowing more but also having become more capable of living responsibly. They should possess stronger intellectual habits, deeper spiritual commitments, greater practical competence, and a clearer sense of vocation.

Of course, these outcomes should not simply be assumed because an institution is small or Christian. A small college can be poorly managed. A close-knit community can become insular. An academically ambitious program can lack sufficient expertise. And a strong emphasis upon formation can become controlling if students are not encouraged to develop mature judgment and personal responsibility.

Families should examine faculty qualifications, academic expectations, financial stability, student outcomes, institutional accountability, and the actual quality of community life. The promise of the formation colleges must be demonstrated, not merely advertised.

Not for Everyone

Formation colleges are not for every student. Some young people need specialized academic programs, extensive laboratory facilities, professional accreditation, or the research opportunities available at larger universities. Others may not be ready for the demands of an intensely communal educational environment. There is no shame in choosing another path.

But for young people who want to be stretched intellectually, challenged personally, deepened spiritually, and prepared for meaningful responsibility, formation colleges deserve serious attention. The most important question is not whether the institution possesses an impressive name. It is whether the educational experience is likely to produce the kind of person the student aspires to become.

This is a different way of measuring value.

The conventional college value proposition focuses heavily upon credentials, career opportunities, and future earnings. These matter. But they do not exhaust the value of education. What is the value of developing sound judgment? What is the value of learning to keep commitments? What is the value of acquiring the courage to lead, the humility to listen, and the discipline to serve? What is the value of discovering a vocation worthy of one’s life? These are difficult things to quantify. But they may prove more consequential than the name printed on a diploma.

The Return on Formation

The future of higher education will not be determined simply by which institutions offer the lowest tuition or the most marketable degrees. It will also depend upon which institutions can make a compelling case for the kind of people their graduates become.

This is where micro colleges, or formation colleges, possess a distinctive opportunity.

They can offer something increasingly difficult to find: an educational environment in which intellectual learning, spiritual development, practical responsibility, and personal maturation reinforce one another. They take seriously the idea that college should be a transition into adulthood rather than a postponement of it. They recognize that the deepest educational outcomes cannot be measured simply by credit hours, graduation rates, or starting salaries. And they understand that a young person’s life is too important to be reduced to the acquisition of a credential.

For students willing to embrace the challenge, the formation college may offer an extraordinary return on investment. Not because it guarantees financial success. Not because it provides a prestigious institutional brand. But because it helps students become the kind of people capable of making a meaningful contribution to the world.

The ultimate question is not simply, what will this college enable me to earn? It is, who will this college help me become?

That is the question parents and students should be asking. And it is the question higher education must learn to answer. A college degree may open the door to a career. A formative education can help prepare a young person for a life worth living. This is the promise of the formation college.

Books by Dr. John Seel, Jr.

image
dr. john seel parenting without peerfection . . .
image

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Featured Posts

Start Here

Daily Devotions

Short reflections to help you begin the day with Scripture, prayer, and steady faith.

Spiritual Growth

Articles that encourage a stronger walk with Christ and a deeper spiritual foundation.

Grandparenting

Encouragement for investing faithfully in the lives of your children and grandchildren.

Family Leadership

Practical wisdom for leading with love, courage, humility, and biblical conviction.

Explore

Latest Devotions

Read devotional reflections written to encourage prayer, Scripture meditation, and faithful living.

Meet the Members

Browse the writers, contributors, and community members connected with Christian Grandfather Magazine.

Apply for Membership

Share your profile for review if you would like to be listed as part of the Christian Grandfather community.

Pure inspiration, zero spam ✨

Discover more from Christian Grandfather Magazine

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading